Carvel's sweet, waxy birthday bonnet confection, and cookie crumbles from Flying Saucer ice cream sandwiches). Do we have your mouthwatering attention yet? The menu also features five more ...

Mara, our senior groceries editor, even compared the ice cream to a "soft serve" at Carvel. Even though it didn't place as the winner, a few of our testers declared this sandwich as their top choice.